NOTES TOWARDS
A DEFINITION OF A MASTERPIECE:
TEN
NEW SONGS
FROM SHARON ROBINSON
AND LEONARD COHEN
by Judith Fitzgerald
To LC
I suppose I might be
considered obsessive about form or order or structure or whatever; but, I
don't think so. It's part of its attractiveness, for one thing. ... Making
Various Positions (1984) was the first time I could really see and
intuitively feel what it was I was doing, making, or creating in that
enterprise. It all just seemed to click. Suddenly, I knew these weren't
discrete songs I was writing. I could see — I could sense — a unity.
Various Positions had its own life, its own narrative. It was all
laid out and all of a sudden it all made sense. — Leonard Cohen
(The Globe and Mail, November 2000)
There's a lot of
taking-away of things that might distract from the whole. ... I wrote a
lot of parts that ended up being taken out. There were parts that I
thought were beautiful. And I'd bring them over, and he'd say, 'That's
beautiful.' Then a minute later, he'd say: 'It's too beautiful. We've got
to get rid of it.' — Sharon Robinson (The Globe and Mail,
October 2001)
Under "Lifer" in the Hurts' Encyclopaedia,
you'll find Leonard Cohen's name illuminated in gold. The guy with the
hurt-on the size of all creation is — not to put too fine a point on it
— a walking compilation of Greatest Hurts.
Long revered for his
willingness to wear his wounds on his sleeve, Cohen's ruinous tunefulness
has always lifted les âmes perdues to jouissant heights, most
likely because the sine qua non of blasted baritones has
always issued straight from the numinous and luminous depths. Think
"Suzanne," "Bird On The Wire," "Last Year's Man," "Hallelujah," "Who By
Fire," "Avalanche," "Joan Of Arc," "Paper Thin Hotel," "Coming Back To
You," or virtually any of the tunes penned since the first of several
certified masterpieces, 1984's Various Positions, was released 16
years after the artist's now-classic breakthrough début, Songs Of
Leonard Cohen, forever altered the popular-music soundscape for the
better 27 December 1967.
Naturally, following the release of his
second (1988's I'm Your Man) and third (1992's The Future)
masterpieces, the general consensus among popular commentarians and
qualified critics was that Cohen could not possibly square the circle a
fourth time (despite the fact it would take almost a decade for him to
bring that highly anticipated platter to market).
Naturally, the
general consensors now eat their words. Ten New Songs is indeed The
Man's fourth masterpiece since Various Positions; however, because
that highly laudatory cognominatio denoting the apotheosis of
aesthetic excellence has lost much of its value, power, and vigour these
past few decades, it is essential to remind readers exactly what a
masterpiece is and, by extension, what a masterpiece does (both in terms
of its intrinsic achievements and extrinsic accomplishments).
The
Fourth Edition of The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English
Language (2000) locates the word's probable etymological roots in the
Dutch "meesterstuker" as well as the German "meisterstück." As its
etymology suggests, a masterpiece is "an outstanding work of art or craft"
which distinguishes itself as a work of superlative perfectitude not only
in relation to its creator's oeuvre but also in relation to the milieu in
which it is created.
In point of fact, the art of the recorded
composition is a relatively recent phenomenon in the history of making a
joyful noiseful. Prior to the advent of the professional recording studio,
few masterpieces were created (or preserved) because pioneer Chet Atkins,
the ace guitarist largely responsible for perfecting both the dynamics of
the acoustic environment as well as many of its soundest principles,
techniques, equipments, and accoutrements (essential to the development of
the emerging medium's aesthetic of excellence vis-à-vis production
values) were generally conceived and created by Atkins on the fly, so to
speak, shortly after WWII.
A multi-tasking Renaissance man of the
virtuoso-guitarist persuasion, Atkins tweaked the fuzz-tone effect,
reverb, tremelo, wah-wah, direct-to-board instrumentation, and the echo
chamber (pioneered by Les Paul), to cite but a couple or few of the
remarkable contributors and contributions to the art and craft works
issuing from the recording studio. Not surprisingly, the first few waves
of resulting masterpieces to make an international splash were analogue
productions created by country, blues, gospel, bluegrass, and rockabilly
artists (Elvis Presley, Roy Orbison, Ray Charles, George Jones, Merle
Haggard, Patsy Cline, Hank Williams, et.al., most notable among
same).
Still, a medium — pioneering spirits and spirited
practitioners notwithstanding — does not a masterpiece make. For that
reason, it is useful to remember that even the most objective of
judgements (based on quantifiables such as technical merit,
instrumentation, repeat listenability, arrangements, production values,
etc.) involves the application of a subjective set of criteria
(originality, durability, novelty, consistency, inspiration, formal
coherence, invention, transformative power, etc.,); consequently,
it is equally instructive to recall at least one way in which
chef-d'oeuvres can be assessed on their own merits:
Does the
composition under scrutiny contain one word, one beat, one bar of sound,
or one measly measure of silence that can be altered, rearranged, or
deleted without radically affecting (improving or diminishing) the work's
overarching intentions, aesthetic integrity, and musical coherence? Once a
determination in favour of the composition's inviolable authenticity has
been rendered, it logically follows that a masterpiece, by its very
existence, redefines the boundaries and scope of the medium in which it is
created and, in some elementary way, transcends genre at the same time;
thus, historically driven aesthetic concepts such as Significant Form only
and always confirm such assessments.
Ten New Songs(Sony
Canada) is a masterpiece. An aural miracle, the disc's an utterly
irresistible breath of fresh ear from a pair of the world's leading unsung
seers. It's an exquisite secular benediction jam-crammed with quotidian
psalms, salutary anthems, consuetudinary hymns, and arie melodiose
cantante a due voci nello stile del crooner lucertole di salotto
expressing the inexpressible to the Nth degree of dramatic
intensity and compressed musicality.
Individually, Robinson and
Cohen are awesome; together, they are sublime. Arguably one of the finest
recorded performances in existence, the retro-deco duet-set comprising the
elegiac song cycle, Ten New Songs, is wholly and fully their
masterpiece worthy of the distinctive honour such a designation implicitly
confers.
Sublimely layered and logically ordered through the
deployment of a variety of structural divisions, developmental directions,
shifting narrative perspectives, and a series of diverse philosophical
positions dependent as much upon the Tradition's canonical elements as
Cohen's self-stylised signature themes, these chansons à deux
parties illuminating "the exploded landscape" of contemporary
existence underscore the current enterprise in all its glorious
manifestations and trademark allusive applications.
Consider, for
digressionary example, the fact Cohen leads off 1968's "One Of Us Cannot
Be Wrong" (Songs Of Leonard Cohen) with an arresting and remarkably
compressed ear-catcher made all the more resonant by virtue of its
affinity with Quebecer Anne Hébert's "La chambre de bois" (Le tombeau
des rois, 1953): "J'aime un petit bougeoir vert," wrote she in 1953.
Cohen respectfully dibbed the concept and transformed "I love a small
green candlestick" into a green-eyed monster of an altogether different
stripe: "I lit a thin green candle to make you jealous of me," confesses
the representative he; but, three brief verses later, the boy with the
badass blues reports the good old news: "The poor man could hardly stop
shivering / his lips and fingers were blue / I suppose that he froze when
the wind / took your clothes / and I guess he just never got warm / but
you stand there so nice / in your blizzard of ice / oh please let me come
into the storm... ."
Despite enumerating nothing but warts, woes,
and worries, the speaker on this heat-seeking slo-mo sizzler certainly
invites felicitous comparison with the primary narrator of Ten New
Songs, particularly in terms of the intersection of the voices'
copacetic views when it all comes down to dust, the singing darkness, long
sleepless nights, honeymoon details, the drooling souls of saints,
blizzards of ice, et so forthia.
Additionally,
intertextually linked phrases overlay allusional theme-markers flagging
earlier sonic and linguistic instances wherein often identical (but always
similar and certainly familiar) emotional, psychological, and spiritual
themes conjoin with psychic landscapes to illuminate aspects of one's
secret (or private) life in comparison with the display of its highly
public counterpart. As Cohen told El Mundo's Elena Pita recently,
"[e]veryone knows that the secret life is the one that parallels the one
we live for appearances; it is the life of deep feelings, of honesty, the
one we can never show; it is the life behind the
mask."
Notwithstanding the life one can never show, right from the
get-go, everybody knows who's running this show: That unmistakable voice
was heard early in the poet's work emerging from the broken shards and
blasted shreds of 1964's Flowers for Hitler in the name of Lot
("Give me back my name / give me back my childhood list / I whispered to
the dust when the path gave out / Now sing / Now sing / sang my master as
I waited in the raw wind"), in the name of the character who reveals
"history is a needle / for putting men asleep, / anointed with the poison
/ of all they want to keep ... Now a name that saved you / has a foreign
taste / claims a foreign body / froze in last year's waste" and, most
acutely, in the name of Love and Death, the twinned themes Robinson and
Cohen celebrate with Ten New Songs.
"Well, we all have a
sense of a truth," allows Cohen in Euroman, "the truth can be the
most intimate conversation with one's heart about its desire and appetite.
And when this conversation appears, it comes very close to the truth and a
feeling of authenticity ... 'I smile when I'm angry. / I cheat and I lie.
/ I do what I have to do / to get by / But I know what is wrong / And I
know what is right / And I'd die for the truth / in my secret life.' To be
understood in the way that you can deceive everybody but yourself. This is
the truth viewed in a simple, pragmatic, and ordinary way, but it isn't
the great truth of our existence."
Nor, really, do such earlier
tunes as "The Stranger Song" (Songs Of Leonard Cohen, 1968) or "The
Window" (Recent Songs, 1979) investigate the great truth of our
existence; rather, they reinforce the value of its understanding. While
the former achieves its effects in terms of the holy game of poker ("Like
any dealer he was watching for the card / that is so high and wild / he'll
never need to deal another" and "Please understand I never had a secret
chart / to get me to the heart of this / or any other matter), the latter
freezes and frames love in its window of lost opportunities (... "lost in
the waves of a sickness / that loosens the high silver nerves / O chosen
love, O frozen love / O tangle of matter and ghost / O darling of angels,
demons, and saints, and the whole broken-hearted host ...").
Then,
suddenly, it's now, it's new, it's next, it's 1992: "Give me back my
broken night / My mirrored room, my secret life," commands the
aggressively urgent narrator in the first lines of the title-tune opening
Cohen's penultimate studio effort; and, by the way, hello, there. Welcome
to the future of The Future where the shattered unseen seer has not
only risen from the ashes of history and splinters of catastrophe but has
also proven he's ready, he's willing, he's raring to identify, codify, and
verify the contents of that secret life he's clearly reclaimed
post-avalanche, post-blizzard, post-dress-rehearsal rag-and-bone-shop art
of the terminally broken heart beating in the breast of any one of the
billions of contemporary anybodies populating the planet.
"I’m not
necessarily the person in all my songs," Cohen explained to Frank
DiGiacomo of The New York Observer (October 2001). Later that same
fall, articulating the salient features of TNS's lead-off in a
special interview, Cohen additionally pointed out the importance of the
fact that the first lines of the first tune on his current speak to
notions of "a love that won't die," of a love that, in his words,
"resurrects itself continually in one's secret life" before clarifying his
position concerning the distinction between first-personal art and
autobiography:
"Well, you know, even though it's an
autobiographical I, it's not consistently that autobiographical I. It
migrates to different positions. The "I" there is one I that I recognise
that I don't necessarily inhabit right now; but, it's something that I've
certainly felt. 'I saw you this morning / You were moving so fast / Can't
seem to loosen my grip / on the past.' That is, you know, we still live in
our memories, especially when it comes to love. When one has experienced
loss — which everybody does — at least half one's songs are about loss.
One half's about finding love; the other half's about losing love. Then,
there's some kind of grey area in the centre which celebrates the love;
but, those are not that common."
Indeed, the work sui
generis contains a suite of celebratory sequences created within the
parameters that grey area circumscribes, a fact serving to further
reinforce the strengths of this uncommonly shaped and lovingly polished
suite à deux voix. Among the most accomplished — and coherent —
recorded compositions ever attempted, its splendid blend of foreground
colour and background texture never dissolves in spectral blackitude;
rather, the universal tone poem — traversing the spectrum and
incorporating the thesis-antithesis-synthesis organising principle of its
creation — incrementally materialises on a Spartan mindscape of intimate
blues, limpid mauves, burnished teaks, and incandescent greys most
obviously apparent in the cycle's first four numbers.
An
adventurous redemption suite infused with fluid grace, literate warmth,
and a hint of sashay sway, Ten New Songs features melodic touches
of countrified gospel seamlessly embellished with smooth R & B
stylings unerringly dipping and slipping way down deep to capture a
profound sense of poise, power, and sonomonopeia™, especially when Cohen
sinks his voice to further deepen the already deep deepery of "a thousand
kisses deep" or slurs his fighting-drunk way through the marbly mouthed
"That Don't Make It Junk," to cite but a pair of sonic TKOs.
Except
for Bob Metzger's glorious guitar riffs on "In My Secret Life," TNS
is completely electronic, a feature of the new CD which may give diehard
aLCholics cause for pause. True B'Losers would hardly expect synthesisers,
sequencers, and drum machines; but, born-to-b'lose aficionados would
hardily and wholeheartedly embravo the pair's novel approach. Eventually.
Upon reflection, it certainly becomes clear the contents, aims, and
methods deployed on the Zen Ten cry out for an extra-human foundation, a
something "other" or else, a stack-'em-up/strip-'em down electronic ground
of sound which affords both musicians and prospective listeners the luxury
of appreciating the subtleties of sonic time filtered through the spacious
warmth of the radically up-front vocal tracks. The glittering musicality
of synchromeshing voices made and meant for each other swaths the
electro-beats with a spangly wash of compellingly stunning yet
appropriately understated vocal gorgeosity.
Accordingly, Ten New
Songs contains gravelly creamy-dreamy croon tunes dissolving the wild
and weary contours of the nameless narrator's ice-bound heart while
concurrently presaging the pallor of things to come for "the millions in a
prison / that wealth has set apart" (currently at loose ends in the
homogenised and sterilised land of plenty). Robinson's ethereally
commanding voice, by far the finest to complement Cohen's to date,
magically wraps itself around the material with such finesse and purity,
it quickly becomes impossible to imagine these irresistible songs in any
but their current setting, so mesmerising is the musical alchemy at work
between this preternaturally perfect pair of lead singers on Ten New
Songs. And, considering the combination of elegance and restraint
immeasurably mellowed by the crisp articulation and compulsive momentum
driving one truly compact disc, Cohen and Robinson telegraph a moving
message culminating in prayerful serenity for the throngs of working
stiffs given over to the throes of organised dissatisfaction run ragged
and rampant in "The Land Of Plenty."
Retro-soul rhythms revel in
the jazzy-bluesy heartwork of pure song and spirit. The coarse and throaty
speech-like timbre of the vox humana proceeds, with escalating
intensity, to unravel the dramatically lyrical lines and sweetly sedate
phrasings of one stunningly melismatic vox angelica gracefully
moving through the shattered soulscape of the present.
The lush and
mellow backbeat rhythms encircling the alto-baritone union are offset by
an encyclopaedic exploration of tonal organisation best evidenced in the
collaborators' decision to forego all but 4/4 (or closely related) time
signatures, a fact which raises a number of questions, the most intriguing
of which might well lead listeners to ponder why there are no waltzes on
the current CD. Sharon Robinson graciously provided her take on their
absence via e-mail: "Time signature is not always an exact science," she
explained, adding that she, too, has "wondered why there are no waltzes on
TNS. I think it's because, in large part, our creative work is not
completely in our hands. A couple of these songs could have perhaps been
written as waltzes, and I remember presenting a few ideas to Leonard in
3/4, but for whatever reason, we liked the straight-ahead feels better for
these particular lyrics."
The straight-ahead feels of these
particular lyrics dominate a disc saturated with ambivalence and tethered
to a tangle of tertiary streams of thought coursing through the minds of
these voices on a first-name basis with Love and Death. Fresh, bright, and
achingly tender, the sensuous and full-bodied richness situates the
soundscape slightly west of World-Beat Street even though its interwoven
mythic threads detour through a cabaret of stark sonorities the dual lead
singers celebrate.
"The album," Cohen thinks, "could be described
as a duet." He thinks? LOL! They gain the light, they formlessly entwine
— one voice, one heart, one dreamscape, darkness sounding depths in the
name of the divine.
Admirably restrained and effortlessly blended
in a chiaroscuro of transcendent tempi, the album's intensely muted
atmosphere reaches out to keep listeners close (but never claustrophobic).
Rich and reverent late-night ballads augment strains of early-morning
benisons glittering with the rising sun hovering on the cusp of the
horizon to create an artistic triumph of tone and timelessness equalling
(or surpassing) the earlier masterworks.
In fact, the low-key
grandeur (accomplished, perhaps, by the dearth of lead-and-harmony vocals
in deference to the dual leads) and touches of classical elegance put one
in mind of those lovely masterpieces Leonardo Da Vinci bequeathed the
world, the ones in which he invented and perfected a trio of painterly
techniques Cohen and Co. seem to have adopted as their own. Suffused with
a fine and palpable sfumato, a haze of acoustic space becomes regal and
tangible as the chiaroscurists shadow dance among the shifting shapes of
atmospheric perspective wedded to the monochromatics of loss within the
dust-flecked formlessness preconfiguring "formless
circumstance."
Such initially jarring juxtapositions ("formless
circumstance," "lawless heart," "invincible defeat") combine with
intentionally startling unpredictabilities (e.g., the use of "piss"
and "pan" on "Here It Is," the disarmingly candid disclosures one of the
dominant narrators makes concerning poseurs, posturing, and prevarication
on "In My Secret Life" or, most tellingly, "the maps of blood and flesh"
now "posted on the door" on "Boogie Street") artlessly recombine with key
P-O-V shifts and subtle sonic reinforcements of the main theme — say,
when the music supports the subject under scrutiny on "Boogie Street" and
intimates those sirenical snake-charmer strains long associated with
Cleopatra — to augment the work's formal organisation and signal
transitions seamlessly dissolving in the stately melodic
flow.
Voluptuously austere and heartbreakingly dignified, many of
the songs re-examine familiar themes in the Book of Eternity (as well as
Cohen's own collected works), from the suitor's disappointing performances
and imperfections to the genuine attempts to reconcile the ravages of life
amid the ruins of time with the very human need to love, be loved, and
achieve immortality through creative engagement in artistic enterprises.
Characteristic of such themes, the major motifs involve aspects of the
lovers' debate and feature several elements and situations germane to its
development, denouément, and conclusion (the ship's voyage, the bridegroom
and the bride, the hunter and the hunted, the lover working at cross
purposes to the Beloved, and so on).
It comes as no surprise Cohen
speaks of "a kind of peaceful feeling that runs through this record," of
the relief or release of "resolution, reconciliation." Spirituality, one
learns, is not the knowledge one learns but the knowledge one suffers in
the little village where everybody knows the score and "for us," as Eliot
avers in Four Quartets, "there is only the trying."
When
Mojo's Sylvie Simmons queried Cohen in November 2001 on
songwriters, songwriting, romantic descriptions, trying to love his
way and such, the tunesmith politely demolished the concept by gently
reminding Simmons said image "has somewhat evaporated. Now I'd say it's
the work of a scavenger. The content of whatever it is you write is a
matter of scavenging around and trying to satisfy this appetite to make
something." (Like Eliot said ... .)
An inveterate scavenger, the
magpie makes raids on the sublime to pick up amusing, enchanting, or
irrefragable strains from such as Robert Frost's "Stopping by Woods on a
Snowy Evening," the ten mystical creative powers emanating from G-d
revealed in the Sephirot emphasising "calling, creating, forming, and
making," the supplicatory Rhyme Royal concluding Edmund Spenser's
"Epithalamion," Keats's "Endymion," "The Everlasting Gospel" by William
Blake, the seventh part of William Wordsworth's "Ode; The Morning of the
Day Appointed for a General Thanksgiving (18 January 1816), "I've Been
Working On The Railroad" ("Someone's in the kitchen with Dinah / Strumming
on the old banjo"), and E. E. Cummings's "Epithalamium," not to mention
Cavafy nor Eliot nor "the latest hit" nor "the wisdom of old"
(a.k.a. Shakespeare, the Bible, the Qur'an, Greek myth, Roman
legend, etc.), among a host of others.
The coolest of
Cohen's creative smirkifications, of course, resides in the delicious
slow-dawning gotcha arising from a comparison between Booby Dylan's
dullicious ditty, "Tangled Up In Blue," with the magnificent heights the
contemporary Commedia's creators conquer. On that 1975 tune, His
Royal Boobyist, one helluva lip-servicing Philistine, literally stooped to
no-name droppings to innervate his psychotic musical melange featuring
some dame from a topless joint opening up "a book of poems ... written by
an Italian poet from the thirteenth century." Ho hum.
Ten New
Songs is essentially an illumination of historical and contemporary
culture that consolidates its binary viewpoint by deploying a series of
speakers who take their turns incrementally advancing the allegorical
narrative at the heart of the matter or the centre of a world (that cannot
hold). Too, in deference to the scaffolding supporting the work
consonantly dripping with bardistic flourishes and dantisti elegance, it
rises up in sonic space and geometric time to construct the contents of
the mind of the twenty-first century: The condition human, the comedy
divine. Grey on grey-matter, giving up the ghost. And, if compression is
as compression does, it almost goes without saying nobody does it better
than Cohen himself — nobody, that is, but Italian poet Dante Alighieri
(1265-1321), the shadow painter who devoted the third act of his life to
creating the Divine Comedy upon which Cohen loosely models the
narrative of Ten New Songs.
The Danteum figures sublimely in
the ten-tune trifurcation mirroring the Inferno, Purgatorio, and Paradiso
in equal measure. It claims pride of place among Shakespeare's Tragedy
of Antony and Cleopatra, the Psalms, Isaiah, Job, key passages from
the New Testament, and so on.
Dante's 14,233-line journey commences
in a dark wood that leads him simultaneously down and through the circles
of hell before ascending through the terraces of purgatory and resurfacing
in heaven, a tri-part sojourn matching the mind and mood of the pilgrim
who has undergone a mental, spiritual, and emotional transformation after
traversing the spectrum from grief, bitterness, sin, and fear to the
joyous acceptance of The Good News. Penned in the complex terza-rima
pentameter invented by the Italian, the epic gathers readers close,
inviting them to participate in the poet's guided tour through hell and
purgatory with the Roman poet, Virgil (Publius Virgilius Maro, 70-19
B.C.), who subsequently hands him over to Beatrice (the Beloved to whom
the epic stands as a timeless memorial) for the heavenly show. Dante
commences his pilgrimage on Good Friday; on Holy Thursday, he embraces the
indescribable light of the Trinity (Love, Loving, Loved) and the newly
revealed mysteries of faith and resurrection through purgation,
illumination, and unification.
Ever-cresting circles within
spherical waves within terza-rima triplets inexorably ferry readers
towards the brilliant still centre of the poem, the multifoliate rose
symbolic of Pentecost and Life Eternal that T. S. Eliot's Prufock would
identify in his love song before the poet breathed new life into "The
Burial of the Dead" (The Waste Land), "neither living nor dead," in
"the heart of light, the silence." The nature of human solitude (combined
with the ever-accelerated pursuit of loneliness) drives the secret at the
heart of the light of the Divine Comedy. Imagine the hell of your
choice. Dante's done there; been that (from the perpetually frying undead
to the plenteous wretches who "have no hope of again dying" to those
encased in ice). Small wonder Cohen elects to revisit the conundrum and
retrace the journey undertaken by an Italian poet from the thirteenth
century.
The Eucharistic nature and intrinsic value of the
experience of life, love, and death are not lost on either Dante or Cohen.
From the anonymous suicide and the wretchedness of say, the disbelieving
liars, prevaricators, child molesters, abominable pedophiles, prodigals,
thieves, misers, traitors, arch-heretics, Boobyists, squanderers,
whoremongers, murderers, sorcerers, idolators, tonsured clerics to
Francesca's kiss to the Purgatorio's Oderisi descanting upon the vanity of
human wishes (cf. Ecclesiastes) and fleeting conquests both
prideful and self-aggrandising for no good reason, the trio of canticles
is well-represented among the suite's three sequences evenly distributed
over ten intermeshing songs of exquisite supplication (where songs 1-4
present the thesis, songs 5-7 the antithesis' and, of course, the
remaining trio synthesises the works).
Canto 24, for example,
provides Dante with a platform to defend his "nove rime," descanting upon
its vernacular sources and inspirations while simultaneously clarifying
what is frequently cited as the Purgatorio’s most celebrated profession of
poetic faith:
I' mi son un che, quando Amor mi spira, noto, e
a quel modo ch'e' ditta dentro vo significando...
("I am one
who, when Love inspires [read: in-spirits] me, takes note, and in that
fashion that Love dictates goes signifying," Purgatorio 24.)
Of
course, the Commedia's three parts correspond to the liturgy's trio
of primary sequences; but, the representation of Christ as the bridegroom
at the sacred wedding (joining together), supported by the Song of Songs
and the symbolic emphasis upon the supreme union of God-Human,
Heaven-Earth, Spirit-Flesh, is not new. Consider, for example, the
medieval carol, "My Dancing Day," wherein Christ sings: "Tomorrow shall be
my dancing day, / I would my true love did so chance. / To see the legend
of my play, / to call my true love to my dance." Hrmm... He's
turning tricks? He's getting fixed? He's back on "Boogie
Street?"
Representations of Christ as lover and dancer coexist with
His association with both the Biblical David and the Greek Orpheus, gods
of music who go south in one heck of a hurry deploying the art of music to
quell the savage beasts guarding the gates in the vicinity of the rivers
dark where the mouth is the antechamber of the heart. His embodiment,
then, at the very least, represents a universally recognised projection of
human perfectitude "attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of
Christ" who "descended into the lower parts of the earth" (Ephesians 4).
By extension, the incarnation, crucifixion, and resurrection aspects of
Christ's death dovetail with related myths of redemption and divine
figureheads (pardoning marine pun), most notably those involving the
Babylonian Ea-Damkina-Marduk, the Egyptian Osiris-Isis-Horus, and the
Greek Zeus-Persephone-Zagreus. (Osiris, Horus, Isis, Ishtar, Demeter,
Hercules, Theseus, Orpheus, et.al. — all did their time in various
conceptions of hell.)
The introductory tune on the song cycle, "In
My Secret Life," serves as a succinct starting point for the journey about
to unravel between your ears; and, speaking of, should you take the time
to peruse the lyrics of these Ten New Songs, you will discover each
and every last line scans beautifully. Look no further than the first two
verses of "In My Secret Life":
I saw you this morning/6 You
were moving so fast/6 Can't seem to loosen my grip/7 On the
past/3 And I miss you so much/6 There's no one in sight/5 And
we're still making love/6 In My Secret Life/5
I smile when I'm
angry/6 I cheat and I lie/5 I do what I have to do/7 To get
by/3 But I know what is wrong/6 And I know what is right/6 And
I'd die for the truth/6 In My Secret Life/5
Dante, now well
on his way through hell in Canto XVII, wants to tell his companions to
hold on to him; but, words fail him, "my voice did not come / As I thought
— Make sure you hold on to me" which, of course, resonates with Cohen's
own exhortation, "Hold on, hold on, my brother / My sister, hold on
tight."
The Inferno's Canto XXI commences with Dante explaining he
and Virgil "travelled on" before stopping to examine another "empty
sorrow. ... And I saw how awesomely dark it was!" cries Dante, recoiling
in horror from the concatenation of human misery and deviltry he's
witnessed as the pair makes its way through that God-forsaken place of
eternal perdition. Similarly, Canto XXIX opens with Dante affirming "the
swarms of people and the sweep of wounds / had left my eyes so blind drunk
with their tears / that still they ached to linger on and
weep."
Looked through the paper Makes you want to
cry Nobody cares if the people Live or die
In Paradiso
II, readers learn "this mingled power shines out through the body" before
discovering that from "[t]his power comes the apparent difference ... the
formal principle which produces, / In proportion to its goodness, the dark
and bright."
... And the dealer wants you thinking That it's
either black or white Thank G-d it's not that simple In My Secret
Life ...
... But I'm always alone And my heart is like
ice And it's crowded and cold In My Secret Life ...
As
the Inferno's Canto XXXII concludes, Dante elaborates on the condition of
things "below in the darkened hole ... of this weary wretched brotherhood"
before he spins around and realises he stands on a lake "so frozen" it
resembles glass with faces literally locked in ice:
After that I
saw a thousand faces so Purpled by cold that a shivering still Grips
me, and it always will, at frozen ponds.
"A Thousand Kisses
Deep," as Cohen hears and sees it, "has its own coherence a thousand
kisses deep. Those words stand for that deeper intuitive understanding of
how things unfold — an acceptance. For instance, I say, 'summoned now to
deal with your invincible defeat.' That is, everybody has this experience
at some point in their lives where things are not going to turn out as
they wished; but, still, we have to make choices and live our lives as if
our lives are real (even though a certain dreamy aspect begins to assert
itself, a certain flimsiness to reality). Nevertheless, you have to make
choices and live your life with the understanding that your life is
unfolding according to patterns and directions that you yourself do not
necessarily determine. But, when you can rest on that understanding,
there's a certain amount of repose."
Early in his career, Cohen had
explored "invincible belief" and investigated "battalions of the wretched"
in the poems of The Spice-Box of Earth (1961). Coming to "A
Thousand Kisses Deep," he describes Boogie Street, deriving from
Singapore's Bugis Street, as that place of quotidian skirmishes and
nocturnal needinesses writ large as well as the symbolic intertwingling
matrix of Babylon and Jerusalem, a feature of the work not only related to
the tune by that name but one which further aligns the song for Sandy with
"Alexandra Leaving," the last of the three middle tunes on the
contemporary Commedia.
"Babylon is what I call 'Boogie
Street,'" Cohen told Thomas Erber October 2001 in Le magazine de
l'optimum, "it is where we are without any real possibility of
escaping from it. And many of the songs on the album speak about this, of
the reconciliation between these two ways of life, because finally, it may
very well be that this holy city of Jerusalem sits right in the middle of
the kingdom of sins, and we are prisoners of these two kingdoms and can
never be in one forever."
Cohen elects to drive the point home when
he slips into the Masterpiece and lovingly refashions a handful of lines
to suit the occasion from Act IV; Scene xv, of Shakespeare's Tragedy of
Antony and Cleopatra:
ANTONY: I am dying, Egypt, dying;
only I here importune death awhile, until Of many thousand kisses
the poor last I lay upon thy lips. ...
I am dying, Egypt,
dying; Give me some wine and let me speak a little.
...
CLEOPATRA: Noblest of men, woo't die? Hast thou no care of
me? Shall I abide In this dull world, which in thy absence is No
better than a sty? O, see, my women, The crown o' th' earth doth melt.
My lord! O, wither'd is the garland of the war, The soldier's pole
is fall'n! Young boys and girls Are level now with men. The odds is
gone, And there is nothing left remarkable. ...
Naturally,
Dante had a thing or two to say about Cleopatra in his Divine
Comedy. (Read 'er and weep.) Of greater interest in this context, the
scavenger Cohen relates how the narrator of "A Thousand Kisses Deep" made
it to "the forward deck" to "bless" his "remnant fleet," echoing Dante's
description of Christ's army "marching on behind the standard / with slow
and straggling steps and scanty numbers" (Paradiso XII). Earlier, in Canto
V of the Paradiso, Dante had also written:
Now, if you reason
from this, you will see The high value of the vow, if it be
such That God gives his consent when you consent.
"For in the
compact between God and humans, This treasure of the will which I
describe Becomes the sacrifice by its own free act." ...
So I
did see more than a thousand splendours Drawing toward us, and in each
I heard, "Look, someone comes who shall augment our
love!"
"That Don't Make It Junk" contains some of Cohen's
favourite lines: "I know that I'm forgiven / But I don't know how I know /
I don't trust my inner feelings / Inner feelings come and go." He explains
he favours those lines because they run "in the face of the current
therapeutic establishment. We're encouraged to feel there's an inner self
that is solid and fixed that's obscured by all kinds of psychological
distractions and trauma and if only we could reach that inner self,
everything will change. My experience is that there is no inner self and
that the quest for it is ill-founded. It's to understand that there is no
inner self — there is no fixed self — that produces a certain sense of
relaxation":
I fought against the bottle But I had to do it
drunk ...
That's a fact Cohen proves slurring his way through
some memorable moments on "That Don't Make It Junk." Fortunately, he and
Dante (and Christ and King David) are loose enough to enjoy a drink or
two. More than once, Dante refers to the grape, prior to opining that
anyone who refuses "to quench your thirst / With the wine from his flask
would be no freer / Than water stopped from flowing to the sea" (Paradiso
X), he notes the following in the Purgatorio's final lines:
If,
reader, I had room to write more lines, I would sing still, in part, of
the sweet drink That kept me thirsting always after more,
But
since all of the pages planned beforehand For this, the second
canticle, are filled, The curb of art lets me run on no
further.
However, the narrator of "That Don't Make It Junk" is
just beginning to loosen up:
...Took my diamond to the pawn
shop But that don't make it junk ...
Cohen's "diamond" —
the almighty talent task-mastered by the Muse herself — cameos on
virtually every studio recording he's created. "Our Lady Of Solitude?"
Tick. "Joan Of Arc?" Tick. "The Ballad Of The Absent Mare?"
Tick. "That Don't Make It Junk?" Natch.
... The woman in
blue, she's asking for revenge the man in white — that's you — says
he has no friends The river is swollen up with rusty cans and the
trees are burning in your promised land And there are no letters in the
mailbox and there are no grapes upon the vine and there are no
chocolates in the boxes anymore and there are no diamonds in the
mine
Well, you tell me that your lover has a broken limb you say
you're kind of restless now and it's on account of him Well, I saw the
man in question, it was just the other night he was eating up a lady
where the lions and Christians fight
And there are no letters in
the mailbox and there are no grapes upon the vine and there are no
chocolates in the boxes anymore and there are no diamonds in the mine
...
The catalogue-crazy narrator of "Diamonds In The Mine,"
say, puts in brief appearances on several of the current cuts, always
listing his achievements, such as they are, in relation to "That Don't
Make It Junk." Thus, when the present narrator confesses, "I tried to love
you my way / But I couldn't make it hold / So I closed the Book of Longing
/ And I do what I am told," he addresses the Muse with an admirable
frankness reminiscent of "I walk through the old yellow sunlight" first
published in The Energy of Slaves (1972):
to get to my
kitchen table the poem about me lying there with the books in
which I am listed among the dead and future Dylans You can
understand I am in no hurry to make the passage The sunlight is old
and yellow a flood of what I laboured to distil a tiny drop of in
that shabby little laboratory called my talent ...
You can
understand. This is not a complaint. This is simply the artist keeping
some kind of record in the name of honouring the gift, the very nature of
the calling demanding complete conscription. You can understand: That
don't make it junk (drug pun notwithstanding).
Now, "Here It Is,"
and the cataloguer cuts loose with a collection of lines that list where
they will. Of the tune he considers "realistic," Cohen says, "'Here It Is'
has a good line in it which is all I have to say and it's kind of
superficial; but, it has a certain minor value: 'May everyone live / And
may everyone die / Hello, my love / And my love, Goodbye.' That repeats
over and over again. Here it is and it's about death. It's nice to write a
catchy tune about death. I don't know of any other songs — I think I
mention death about seven times in that song. Sharon produced a very
jaunty and hypnotic track for it. People like it."
Dante would no
doubt understand this. In the final Canto of the Inferno, overcome by all
he has witnessed and seen, his eyes sweep over "Dis ... the place / Where
you must arm yourself with steadfastness," as Virgil explains to him.
Overwhelmed, Dante attempts an explanatory description but can go no
further when he discovers that everyone doesn't live and everyone doesn't
die, not in the Inferno, not when they're trapped in a hell of their own
devising:
How faint and frozen, reader, I grew then Do not
inquire: I shall not write it down, Since all my words would be too few
and weak.
I did not die and still I did not live. Think for
yourself — should you possess the talent — What I became, robbed of
both life and death!
At various points in his journey, Dante
launches into improvisations and variations on standards, beginning one
such with "Our Father" in Canto XI of the Purgatorio — "Pure form and
matter and the two combined / Came into being which was wholly
flawless..." — not unlike the way in which Cohen and Robinson merge
voices refashioning and renewing various tertiary streams bearing directly
upon the "formless circumstance" at the centre of Ten New Songs.
The Divine Comedy may well provide structural foundation for the
set; but, in the name of all that is hallowed, righteous, and de
rigueur, the modernist minimalist would not stop there, especially
since the incorrigible magpie rarely resists the beautiful trope, exotic
figure, or well-turned phrase alive with aesthetic possibilities in all
matters allusive.
Reader, you clearly see I elevate My theme:
you should not wonder then if I Try to raise my style with ampler
art.
Dante blazed new territory raising up the beauty of the
Italian vernacular to adorn spectacular vistas with a new style, a
vocabulary enriched as much by the magnificent and sublime as the secular
and mundane or the sacred and profane best expressed as the squalor and
the splendour. He elevated his very human themes using language
appropriate to the occasion. As does Cohen. Look no further than "Here It
Is," the very tune that will, no doubt, make Irving Layton roar (no doubt,
for more).
As Cohen explains, "'Love Itself' is a kind of central
song — not that I expect anybody to study the record with any intensity
because it took a long time to write — but, the record does have a kind
of development and that's one of the central songs which describes an
experience where that self is dissolved for a moment; that mask is taken
off; and, when that happens, 'I'll try to say a little more / Love went on
and on / Until it reached an open door / Then love itself / Love itself
was gone.' So, that love that I'm speaking there is not the opposite of
hate and it's not romance; it's the kind of love that embraces ordinary
love and spiritual love and all the requirements of the mind to wrap
itself around the word, 'love,' because, in this kind of experience, that
tyranny is dissolved and even the need to love is dissolved. So, that's
where real relaxation arises. When all the requirements of spiritual
perfection, all the ambition of spiritual aspiration, are dissolved and
you can just relax into ordinary humanness."
That experience,
lasting for "something like a second," provides the central experience of
the ten songs. Dissolution involves an absence of "self" and "ego" (or,
perhaps, "I" and "it"). These ideas and concepts have always dominated
Cohen's literary landscape, from "You Have the Lovers" (TSBOE)
where "the door is opened to the lover's chamber / The room has become a
dense garden, / full of colours, smells, sounds you have never known" to
the transfiguring lines concerning "[m]arble and calm / And what happened
to love / In the gleaming universe? / It froze in the heart of G-d, /
Froze on a spear of light" located in "Brighter Than Our Sun"
(TSBOE).
The light came through the window Straight
from the sun above And so inside my little room There plunged the
rays of Love In streams of light I clearly saw The dust you seldom
see... .
Considering the way, the truth, and the light, Dante
appropriately reports, in Paradiso II:
I thought we were
enveloped in a cloud, Shining, solid, dense, and highly polished As
a diamond struck by the sun would be. ...
And that heaven which
myriad lights make lovely Takes its image from the deep Mind that turns
it And of that image makes itself the seal.
And as the soul
within this dust of yours Has been diffused throughout the different
members To suit each one to some distinctive function,
"So the
Intelligence deals out its goodness By multiplying itself among the
stars As it revolves on its own unity."
Earlier, again in
Purgatorio XI, Dante writes:
I would now gaze upon this man who
lives But remains nameless, to see if I know him And to make him
feel compassion for my load. ...
Cohen responds, "Out of which
the Nameless makes / A Name for one like me."
Dante admits defeat:
"I cannot here describe them all in full / For my lengthy theme so presses
me forward / That often words fall short of the occasion."
Cohen
rises to the pivotal occasion:
... I'll try to say a little
more Love went on and on Until it reached an open door Then Love
Itself Love Itself was gone ...
Nevertheless, midway through
the Paradiso, Dante experiences an epiphany:
"Faith is the
substance of things that are hoped for And the evidence of things that
are not seen, And this appears to me to be its essence."
And
this appears to be the essence of "formless circumstance":
...
All busy in the sunlight The flecks did float and dance And I was
tumbled up with them In formless circumstance ...
... Then I
came back from where I'd been My room, it looked the same But there
was nothing left between The Nameless and the Name ...
"You
act like one who clearly apprehends / A thing by name, but cannot grasp
its essence," observes Dante in Paradiso XX.
... All busy in the
sunlight The flecks did float and dance And I was tumbled up with
them In formless circumstance ...
It is said Buddhist monks
chant to achieve "self-lessness," that state where consciousness renders
formless any conceptual notion of form in terms of the Divine. Not unlike
the Jewish or Moslem pilgrim, not to mention the Christian monk, the
Divine dissolves both formally and temporally while retaining the
character of formless circumstance, the transcendent act of other-directed
meditation, contemplation, or prayer where the relationship towards the
other takes precedence.
To add a little more, Cohen certainly
noodles around in the wordshop / workship of the nominal in many of his
earlier compositions such as "Hallelujah," "The Guests," and even "The
Great Event" (1997) where playing the "Moonlight Sonata backwards ... will
reverse the effects of the world's mad plunge into suffering, for the last
200 million years."
Of course, Cohen's narrator does say a little
more, with gusto, as the divine duo takes up residence on the observation
deck to catch strains of Shakespeare's Antony telling Cleopatra "I am
dying, Egypt, dying; / Give me some more wine and let me speak a little
..."
Naturally, King David in Purgatory X, also deserves his
mots justes prior to the occasion, at least as far as Dante's
concerned:
... There in the vanguard of the sacred
coffer, Dancing with robes hitched up, the humble psalmist So proved
himself both more and less than king.
Opposite, depicted at the
window Of a stately palace, Michal watched him dance, So like a
woman filled with wrath and scorn. ...
"'By the rivers dark / I
wandered on / I lived my life / in Babylon...' That song — ['By The
Rivers Dark'] — just participates in that whole idea of the resolution
between ordinary life and some other idea we have of it, of Boogie Street
and some other version of profundity that we might nourish in ourselves;
but, we're all on Boogie Street and we're all in Babylon. And, that song's
about the reconciliation of Babylon with Jerusalem, of the Holy Land and
the profane land. We keep moving between those ideas in our lives; but,
really, they're the same place."
Around the same time Cohen sat for
the special interview cited above, France's Thomas Erber, in Le
magazine de l'optimum, reported the peregrinations of a character in
Canada reporting the peregrinations of a character in Babylon. Of the song
"By The Rivers Dark," the Canadian reports:
"This song reports the
peregrinations of a character in Babylon. He's part of it, then flees it,
comes back to it ... He belongs to the City of depravities while he knows
there's a Jerusalem somewhere, even if he doesn't figure out what's going
on there. It's like our thoughts. Our brain is a receptacle for thoughts
just as we are for love. One doesn't really know what's rising in us the
next moment. But our nature drives us to think we master these streams,
while we master them no more than the location we're born in. We spend too
much time thinking we're able to deny, to disown our roots, and our
condition. This story is reflected in the character, except the fact he
finally really understood where he comes from. Even if an Eden exists, he
does come from Babylon and has to face this, what will surely enable him
to enjoy more the idea of a distant place, necessarily better. ... Of
course! Babylon is what I call 'Boogie Street,' it is where we are without
any real possibility of escaping from it. And many of the songs on the
album speak about this, of the reconciliation between these two ways of
life, because finally, it may very well be that this holy city of
Jerusalem sits right in the middle of the kingdom of sins, and we are
prisoners of these two kingdoms and can never be in one
forever."
Elsewhere, the Canadian reports "By The Rivers Dark" was
inspired by Psalm 137 which, tellingly, is not one of King David's
compositions although King David — considered the founder of the Judean
dynasty of Jerusalem, a national hero, and a spiritual father of Judaism
— is considered the primary author of the Psalms.
Babylon —
which, incidentally, roughly translates as "gate of God" and not as
"confusion" — for various reasons, is aligned with the corrupt human
world in contradistinction from the blessed and holy city of Jerusalem.
Dante, for what it's worth, speaks disparagingly of the gold in Babylon in
Canto XXIII of the Paradiso. The logic for this association between
Dante's voyage and the contrasted cities involves the profound impact the
Babylonian Exile (586-537 B.C.E.) had upon the people of Judah. Psalm 137
speaks of (and to) that experience, felicitously capturing the righteous
anger and sorrowful indignation of its effects. "How shall we sing... ?"
sings its author, thereby creating a psalm about not being able to sing, a
fact most often lost on those who come to the searing Psalm 137 (KJV) for
the first time:
By the rivers of Babylon, there we sat down,
yea, we wept, when we remembered Zion. We hanged our harps upon the
willows [or poplars] in the midst thereof. For there they that carried us
away captive required of us a song; and they that wasted us required of us
mirth, saying, Sing us one of the songs of Zion. How shall we sing the
LORD's song in a strange land? If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right
hand forget her cunning. If I do not remember thee, let my tongue cleave
to the roof of my mouth; if I prefer not Jerusalem above my chief joy.
Remember, O LORD, the children of Edom in the day of Jerusalem; who said,
Rase it, rase it, even to the foundation thereof. O daughter of Babylon,
who art to be destroyed; happy shall he be, that rewardeth thee as thou
hast served us. Happy shall he be, that taketh and dasheth thy little ones
against the rocks.
Incidentally, cunning or skill
etymologically relates to kenning, a figurative word or phrase found in
Old English and Old Norse poetry, e.g., "breast-coffer" = heart or
"storm of swords" = battle. Cunning derives from the Middle-English
present-participle of connen as well as the Old-English
cunnan, to know.
Cohen would not be the first to return
(again and again) to this tiny perfect monument. Its charms were not lost
on, say, among others, Alexander Pope who, in translating Homer's
Iliad (Book 22, 89-91), wrote: "My heroes slain, my bridal bed
o'erturned, / My daughters ravished, and my city burn'd, / My bleeding
infants dashed against the floor; / These have I yet to see, perhaps yet
more."
In 1815, Lord Byron released his translation of Psalm
137:
By the Rivers of Babylon We Sat Down and
Wept
1 We sat down and wept by the waters Of Babel, and
thought of the day When our foe, in the hue of his slaughters, Made
Salem's high places his prey; And ye, oh her desolate
daughters! Were scattered all weeping away.
2 While sadly we
gazed on the river Which rolled on in freedom below, They demanded
the song; but, oh never That triumph the stranger shall know! May
this right hand be withered for ever, Ere it string our high harp for
the foe!
3 On the willow that harp is suspended, Oh Salem!
its sound should be free; And the hour when thy glories were
ended But left me that token of thee: And ne'er shall its soft tones
be blended With the voice of the spoiler by me!
Thus, when
Cohen adds his deux cents to the Tradition, the genius refashions
it to create an opening for his own holy song concerning "the rivers
dark," the five rivers of hell which flow in opposition to Eden's four
rivers of Paradise.
Probably of Babylonian origin, Eden means
steppe; Paradise (literally, garden or pleasure garden) is situated there.
The four rivers of Paradise (deriving from a singular source) flow into
our world from the secretly situated Eden after passing under the ocean
and resurfacing as the Tigris (happily skipping stream), Euphrates
(freshwater stream), Phison (out-flowing stream), and Gehon/Nile
(uplifting or pioneering stream). "And he shewed me a pure river of water
of life, clear as a crystal, proceeding out of the throne of God and of
the Lamb. In the midst of the street of it, and on either side of the
river, was there the tree of life, which bare twelve manner of fruits and
yielded her fruit every month: and the leaves of the tree were for the
healing of the nations" (Revelation 22). Psalm 65 recalls "the river of
God, which is full of water," suggesting that Paradise is the Church of
Christ made possible through His death of reconciliation. (The Tree of
Life alongside the Sephirot cannot be overlooked in this context.) On the
other end of things, the five rivers of hell — Acheron (woe), Lethe
(oblivion), Styx (hatred), Phlegethon (fire), and Cocytus (lamentation) —
encircle the Inferno.
By the rivers dark I wandered on I
lived my life In Babylon ...
The truth of this attenuated
salvo is written in the songs themselves. With the release of his first
recorded composition, Songs Of Leonard Cohen (1968), the artist
serves notice his songs are "Stories Of The Street" populated with
"children of the dust" and "hunters who are shrieking now." On "Last
Year's Man" (Songs Of Love And Hate, 1971) Bethlehem is
characterised as the bridegroom and Babylon the bride ("Great Babylon was
naked oh she stood there / Trembling for me / and Bethlehem inflamed us
both / Like the shy one at some orgy") while "the whore and the beast of
Babylon" put in an appearance on "Is This What You Wanted" from New
Skin For The Old Ceremony (1974). Cohen's no stranger to panic (and
the situation surrounding it), as even a cursory inventory of his
repertoire demonstrates. Still, it behooves one to additionally note, In
"Ballad Of The Absent Mare" (Recent Songs, 1979), "the river's in
flood / and the roads are awash / and the bridges break up / in the panic
of loss." By the time he comes to record Various Positions (1984),
Cohen will inadvertently foreshadow the shape of things to come by
presenting a somewhat finished vision of the entire occasion when his
narrator sings, on "Dance Me To The End Of Love," the following
lines:
Dance me to your beauty with a burning violin Dance me
through the panic till I'm gathered safely in ...
... Oh let me see
your beauty when the witnesses are gone Let me feel you moving like
they do in Babylon ...
... Dance me to the wedding now, dance me on
and on Dance me very tenderly and dance me very long We're both of
us beneath our love, we're both of us above Dance me to the end of love
...
In "The Priest Says Goodbye" (TSBOE), the narrator
recounts how "we name beautiful the smells / that corpses give and
immortelles." Immediately, he adds, "I have studied rivers: the waters
rush / like eternal fire in Moses' bush ...." Three years later, again
returning to familiar territory, Cohen's narrator in "For Anyone Dressed
in Marble" (FFH) considers "the scar of naming in his eye / Bred
close to the ovens, he's burnt inside. / Light, wind, cold, dark — they
use him like a bride" even as the speaker of "On Hearing a Name Long
Unspoken" (FFH) reports on his very human condition: "... hungry
and shrewd / and I am with the hunted quick and soft and nude ...." Dante,
in describing "the marshland that is called the Styx," notes, in the
Inferno (VII) that "the water was far darker than black
dye."
... By the rivers dark Where I could not see Who was
waiting there Who was hunting me ...
Virgil instructs Dante
in Purgatorio XV: "And he told me, "Because you still affix / Your
intellect to the things of the world, / You gather darkness out of the
true light."
... And he cut my lip And he cut my heart So
I could not drink From the river dark
And he covered me And I
saw within My lawless heart And my wedding ring ...
By
1992, the narrator of "Anthem" (The Future) will confess he can no
longer run "with that lawless crowd / while the killers in high places /
say their prayers out loud." Interestingly, in Purgatorio XX, the Italian
further notes, "I see the new Pilate so cruel that / This will not placate
him, but lawlessly / He heads his greedy sails into the
temple."
I did not know And I could not see Who was
waiting there Who was hunting me
The folkloric "Pan's
Anniversary" (or "Shepherds' Holiday") begins, "Of Pan we sing, the best
of singers, Pan" prior to identifying the Greek god as "the best of
hunters, Pan, Arcadian / That drives the heart to seek unused ways / ...
And while his powers and praises thus we sing, / The valleys let rebound,
and all the rivers sing."
... By the rivers dark I panicked
on I belonged at last To Babylon ...
For his part, Dante
introduces "a panic fright" (Dryden) in the opening lines of the
Commedia:
... But when I had reached the base of a
hill, There at the border where the valley ended That had cut my
heart to the quick with panic,
I looked up at the hill and saw its
shoulder Mantled already with the planet's light That leads all
people straight by every road.
With that my panic quieted a
little After lingering on in the lake of my heart Through the night
I had so grievously passed. ...
Well into Purgatory III, just
prior to commenting, tongue-in-cheek, the family tree has become "so
stunted," Dante describes his own doubt arising from the panic of
loss:
... I whirled around to my side in a panic That I had
been abandoned when I saw The ground had darkened only there before
me.
And my comfort, turning full circle, said, "Why this deep
distrust? Do you doubt that I am still with you here and guide you on?"
...
Panic, the word itself, derives from the French
panique (terrified), which has its origins in the Greek "Pnikos, of
Pan," in terms of the terror wrought upon flocks and herds, particularly
since the causing of sudden fright or fear was ascribed to
Pan.
... Then he struck my heart With a deadly force And
he said, This heart It is not yours ...
Naturally, by the
time Dante's grown used to Paradise (XVII) and his eyes have adjusted to
its light, he is able to report: "... I clearly see, my father, how time
spurs / Toward me to strike me such a blow as falls / The heaviest on him
who heeds it least. ... ."
... Though I take my song From a
withered limb Both song and tree They sing for him
Be the
truth unsaid And the blessing gone If I forget My Babylon
...
Now, Dante, coming to the conclusion of the
transformational experience of Purgatory (XXVII), will lay it on the line,
thanks to Virgil:
"Await no more a word or sign from me. Your
will is straightened, free, and whole — and not To act upon its
promptings would be wrong:
"I crown and mitre you lord of your
self."
A prophet of panic? Hardly. The narrator, the one
heading for Boogie Street, is equipped for the occasion by the rivers
dark; but, before he is purged of sin (peccatum), he will have to
say goodbye to "Alexandra Leaving," based on Constantine P. Cavafy's poem
"The god abandons Antony," the last of the trio of purgatorially driven
tunes that create a space, a clear and open place, for the forgiveness of
reconciliation, a forgiveness created on the principle that darkness is to
space what silence is to sound, that is, the interval.
Suddenly
the night has grown colder The god of love preparing to
depart Alexandra hoisted on his shoulder They slip between the
sentries of the heart ...
Whether sentry or sepulchre, Dante is
pushed "between the sepulchres" by Virgil before Virgil commands him to
"suit your words to the occasion" (Inferno X) which, of course, Dante
eventually does (in Paradiso XXVI); additionally, as Dante foreshadows his
own cumulative vision that will draw the Divine Comedy to a close,
so Cohen here, in reference to "a fitful dream, the morning will exhaust,"
does likewise, providing a neat sweet little foretaste of "Boogie Street"
in the process:
... And as a shaft of sunlight shatters
sleep When the spirit of one’s eyesight runs to meet The radiance
that spreads from lid to lid,
And one who wakes up shrinks from
what he sees, His mind befuddled by the sudden rousing, Until his
judgement comes to help him out,
So Beatrice scattered every speck
away From my eyes with the beaming of her own Which shone back down
a thousand miles and more ...
For "you who had the honour of
her evening / And by the honour had your own restored / Say goodbye to
Alexandra leaving / Alexandra leaving with her lord ... ." For his part,
in keeping with the occasion which presents itself in Paradiso XXX, Dante
confesses "the beauty" he saw "transcends all measure" and he must admit
he is "defeated":
For as the sun confounds the feeblest
sight, So the remembrance of her fresh sweet smile Severs my memory
from my sense of self.
From the first day on which I saw her
face In this lifetime, until that sight of her, My song has never
stopped from following her.
But now must my pursuit cease
following Her beauty further in my poetry, Like any artist come to
his full limit.
So I leave her to nobler heralding Than the
sounding of my trumpet which here draws Its arduous subject matter to a
close...
In reference to "Alexandra Leaving" during the
interview, Cohen begins by identifying what he considers to be its good
lines: "You who had the honour of her evening / And by the honour had your
own restored / Say goodbye to Alexandra leaving / Alexandra leaving with
her lord," before acknowledging, "Yes, it's a certain take on loss which
is the take that you don't lose anything, that there's nothing to be lost.
It's difficult to comment on these songs because the writing of them took
so long and almost everything that I wanted to say in those songs is
written in the lyrics which took a great deal of time and effort — not
that that's any guarantee of their excellence — but, to speak
spontaneously and casually about something that is already carefully
formed, somehow trivialises the song itself. A song has its own resonances
and, if it works, it has its own suggestions, its own invitations. So,
when you try to describe exactly what they are, in some way, you spoil the
invitation.
"That song, curiously enough, began as a translation of
a Greek poem by
Cavafy, a very great modern Greek poet. He lived in Alexandria. Many
of his poems were about the city, Alexandria. I tried to translate one of
his poems — I started the translation in '85; and, it's only when
Alexandria changed into Alexandra that I began to be able to translate his
poem into another kind of form that still reflected, I think, his original
intention."
It would seem, too, that the narrator who admits, "In
My Secret Life," of his inability to loosen his grip on the past, has
carefully plodded along with Dante on his symbolic journey towards
release, respite, acceptance, and reconciliation and is, now, able to come
to terms with "strategies like this" in the name of "someone long prepared
for the occasion," fully in command of every wrecked plan, primarily
because he is incapable of choosing "a coward's explanation / that hides
behind the cause and the effect." Dante, in Canto XX of the Paradiso, puts
his finger on it (or, as Cohen would have it, in the wound of
it):
O predestination, how far removed Your root lies from
the eyesight of those people Who do not see the First Cause as a
whole!
The connections between the Cavafy and Cohen poems are
self-evident and true. Cohen completed the song — begun in 1985 upon
falling in love with "The god forsakes Anthony" (1911) — after happening
upon his first draft of it in a drawer and changing "Alexandria" to
"Alexandra." Cavafy, of course, had fallen equally in love with Plutarch's
version of the famous story concerning the fact Caesar left Alexandria, a
seaport on the Nile's left bank, to Queen Cleopatra (46 B.C.); but, in 30
B.C., the conquering Octavius declared the Egyptian kingdom a Roman
province. The poem recounts the way in which the defeated and bereft
Antony heard instruments and voices in the streets just before he passed
out. It is said Antony's protector, Bacchus (Dionysus), had deserted him
(as Shakespeare points out in the salient passage cited earlier): "I am
dying, Egypt, dying; only / I here importune death awhile, until / Of many
thousand kisses the poor last / I lay upon thy lips... / ... I am dying,
Egypt, dying; Give me some wine and let me speak a little...."
By
the time Cohen and Robinson tackle "You Have Loved Enough," the narrator
has indeed become emboldened and does, indeed, say "a little
more."
I said I'd be your lover You laughed at what I
said I lost my job forever I was counted with the dead
I
swept the marble chambers But you sent me down below You kept me
from believing Until you let me know
That I am not the one who
loves It's love that seizes me When hatred with his package
comes You forbid delivery ...
Of course, Cohen returns to
the core, the source, the centre, in all felicitous applications of that
word (including the one on Top of Mount Baldy where, during his five-year
retreat, he served his Roshi). Yet, teachers such as Roshi and Layton (who
cameo frequently in this song cycle) notwithstanding, Cohen here recalls
Dante's experience with love's so-called seizure in Canto V of the Inferno
(which foreshadows the one to come in the Purgatorio):
Love
which takes quick hold in a gentle heart Seized this man for the beauty
of the body Snatched from me — how it happened galls me!
Love
which pardons no one loved from loving Seized me so strongly with my
pleasure in him That, as you see, it still does not leave
me....
By the time he's on his way out of Purgatory (XXIV), he
reiterates the poem's central point:
And I told him, "I am one
who, when Love Inspires me, takes note, and in the manner That he
dictates to me, I set it down."
Back to the future, and
Paradise, where Dante turns to his readers and exclaims, "Imagine, reader,
if what I now begin / Went no further on, how you would feel / an
anguished hunger to know more about them, / And you will see, all on your
own, how I / Hungered to hear more of their condition / The moment they
were shown before my eyes."
... And when the hunger for your
touch Rises from the hunger You whisper, You have loved
enough Now let me be the Lover ...
Hunger (often collocated
with Beauty), literally and figuratively, recurs throughout Cohen's
lifework. From The Spice-Box of Earth's "It Swings Jocko" ("I want
to be hungry, / hungry for food, / for love, / for flesh ... If I am
hungry / then I am great ...") published in 1961 to 1968's "A Bunch of
Lonesome Heroes" (Songs From A Room) where "some of us are very
hungry now / to hear what it is you've done that was so wrong" to "the
witness of a hungry man" and "I left you for another hungry man" in The
Energy of Slaves (1972) to the Phil Spector 1977 co-write, "Memories,"
on Death Of A Ladies' Man ("I know you're hungry / I can hear it in
your voice") to, among others, perhaps some of the most moving lines
penned in the name of love and loss in all of literature, 1974's "Take
This Longing" (New Skin For The Old Ceremony):
... Hungry
as an archway through which the troops have passed I stand in
ruins behind you with your winter clothes your broken sandal strap
...
"You have loved enough; now, let me be the lover.
You can say that the world or G-d or totality or consciousness or your
lover is speaking to you. It just means, like, forget it. Lean back and be
loved by all that is already loving you; it is your effort at love that is
preventing you from experiencing it. When the hunger for your touch, when
whatever it is that you want, whatever it is that seems to be an urgent
necessity — and 'seems to be' does not describe it, it is an
urgent necessity — if you can hear that whisper from your life itself,
from the deepest resource of that activity that is keeping you alive, that
promotes life, that is responsible, that is the engine of life — if you
can hear a whisper from that activity that says, Lean back and experience
the love that is already surrounding you.
"It's like, if you've
ever taught kids how to swim, the most difficult thing is for them to
understand that they'll float if they relax; if they hold their breath and
relax, they will actually float. Most kids — the ones that find it
difficult to swim — feel that they're going to sink like a stone to the
bottom of the lake. So, it's just that understanding that you're going to
float.
"Now, the circumstances may not be continually blissful. I
mean, Jesus Christ Himself cried out, Why hast thou forsaken me? So, that
cry is a human cry; but then, afterwards, He said, Consumatum est.
It is done. This is the way it is; this is the way it happened.
Then, He was able to give up the ghost.
"But, if you bump into a
teaching that invites you to relax in your efforts at love, in your
efforts at spiritual achievement, if you bump into such a teaching — and
that's not in your hands either — and if you can accept to whatever
degree you can accept it — even to accept that you can't accept it —
every degree of acceptance, no matter how remote it is from the full
embrace, confers its own degree of peace."
A decade ago, Cohen
called love "the only engine of survival." Here, now, he underscores the
message of Ten New Songs: Love has become, for the narrator, "the
engine of life."
It may be instructive, at this point, to note one
of the acknowledged founders of the Church, the Jewish Philo of Alexandria
(d. 50 A.D.), lamented the scarcity of quality initiates willing to bring
The Good Word to the populace. "If," remarked he, "there be any as yet
unfitted to be called a son of God, let him press to take his place under
God's first-born son, the Logos, who holds the eldership among the angels,
their ruler as it were, for the Word is the eldest-born image of God."
Through the Logos made flesh "full of grace and truth" (John 1), God
conjoins the finite with the infinite to conflate times past, present, and
future or eternity in a handful of dust.
Identifying Jesus as
Christianity's hierophantic torch-bearer (or humanity's life light), Titus
Flavius Clemens, better-known as Clement of Alexandria (d. 215 A.D.),
considered Greek philosophy a divinely inspired enterprise ennobled by the
act of "perfecting man as man." In the Gospel of Thomas, Jesus connects
Joseph with his divine father and Mary with his divine mother, the Holy
Ghost; yet, when Moses asks for "the name" he should communicate to the
children of Israel, G-d cryptically responds, "I AM THAT I AM" (Exodus
3), and foreshadows Cohen's own take on all of that: "I'm what I am and
what I am / Is back on Boogie Street."
[Aye, aye, PopEye. Jesus was
a sailor, too, you know?]
"Well, 'Boogie Street' begins with
Sharon's impeccable gospel rendering of the chorus. Because she's such a
modest person, I had to insist that she begin the song that way — as I
had to insist that we keep all the tracks that she thought were demos, and
all the elaborations that she thought would later be replaced by live
instruments. When I saw the scope of her gift, I began to understand that
we had the record. We didn't need to replace any of the
sounds.
"So, I insisted that Sharon begin the song; and, she
presented me with this incredible rendering of that verse, 'O Crown of
Light, O Darkened One / I never thought we'd meet / You kiss my lips, and
then it's done / I'm back on Boogie Street.' I never thought I'd have the
experience of this reconciliation of what seemed to be apparent and
irreducible conflicts. You kiss my lips; and then, it's done: I'm back on
Boogie Street.
"So, when you hug your children, you dissolve; when
you kiss your Beloved, you dissolve; when you have some kind of experience
of the totality of this life, you dissolve; but, immediately, you return
to Boogie Street. As my teacher says, You can't live in Paradise because
there are no toilets nor restaurants. So, we're continually entering
Paradise; and, the thing that gets us is we want to say there, we want it
to continue; but, it's not in the nature of things for it to persist.
Immediately, you're thrust back on Boogie Street. If you let yourself go
back, gracefully — and that's not in your hands — if you can return
gracefully to Boogie Street, you return with the residue of the experience
that is not Boogie Street."
O Crown of Light, O Darkened
One I never thought we'd meet You kiss my lips, and then it's
done I'm back on Boogie Street
As Cohen told LA
Weekly's Brendan Bernhard (September 2001), "Boogie Street" is a
metaphor for "ordinary human struggle and life, the place of work and
desire. It's where we're meant to be, it's what we're born into. There are
moments when the burden of the self is lifted, but those are only
temporary situations. As I say in the song, 'You kiss my lips and then
it's done / I'm back on Boogie Street.' Whatever the experience is — the
god, the woman, the insight, the epiphany, the penetration — those are
temporary events."
... A sip of wine, a cigarette And then, it's
time to go ...
What with all the booze floating around Ten
New Songs, and the narrator of "Boogie Street" sipping wine, having a
smoke, and then, needing to hawk a whizz...
[Erp. Make that a
double take:]
"... A sip of wine, a cigarette / And then it's time
to go ..." correlates with Dante's admission in Paradiso XXVII that, at
the moment "[t]he whole of paradise at once poured forth," he heard a song
so sweet he "felt inebriated":
What I saw seemed to me to be a
smile Of the universe, so that my intoxication Came over me from
hearing and from sight.
O gladness! O ineffable elation! O life
entirely filled with love and peace! O riches, free from every other
longing!...
["So I closed the Book of Longing / and I do what I
am told."]
... And O my love, I still recall The pleasures
that we knew The rivers and the waterfall Wherein I bathed with you
...
Does the narrator perhaps recall "The Flowers That I Left
in the Ground" (TSBOE), where "as with horses' manes and
waterfalls. / This is my last catalogue. / I breathe the breathless / I
love you, I love you — / and let you move forever?"
...
Bewildered by your beauty there I'd kneel to dry your feet By such
instructions you prepare A man for Boogie Street ...
A
"glutton," "winebibber," and Orphean-like charmer who consorted with
publicans, sinners, and no-count delinquents (Matthew 11), Jesus, the
Davidic ancestor, dallied with women of questionable repute as well as
inflaming salubrious men of the sword to press forth into battle in the
name of God's Kingdom. Luke 7 relates the story of a "city woman"
[a.k.a. a dame of ill-repute] who finds Jesus in the house of Simon
and commences weeping until His feet are awash in tears; she then dries
His feet with her hair before kissing and anointing them. Mary Magdelan,
in the New Testament, similarly washes and anoints His feet while, at the
Last Supper, Jesus bathes the feet of His disciples.
So come, my
friends, be not afraid We are so lightly here It is in love that we
are made In love we disappear
In expanding upon the lines,
"It is in love that we are made / In love we disappear," Cohen allows, in
November 2001's Mojo, that they're "just a journalistic reportage
of the process. We are made in love and in love we disappear. But that
love is not the romantic love, it's the impersonal benign activity that
governs creation and destruction."
Regarding the crown of light and
the one who ends the dark, Dante describes a similar phenomenon and
reports upon what might well have been a corona borealis in
Paradise.
The "enraptured" poet, "moved with loving," hears
heartbreakingly tender hymns of comfort and joy emanating from within the
cross itself. The Corona Borealis, a half-crescent of stars also known as
the Northern Crown, occasionally seems to disappear from the sky when
sought by the naked eye; but, in fact, it regularly obscures [cf.
chiaroscuro, from Latin "clarus + obscurus" = "clear dark"] itself with
carbon soot, not unlike coal dust or ash. As well, the progress of a total
solar eclipse may well figure in the firmament of Ten New Songs ("O
Crown of Light / O Darkened one / I never thought we'd meet
...").
During a total solar eclipse, the moon takes a small "bite"
from the sun's western edge as the sun slowly disappears. Droplets of
light become noticeable. Daylight fades to black (but not before
alternating bands of light and dark shadow materialise in parallel
sequences). Fifteen seconds before totality, lucent flecks (resembling a
string of beads) yield to the so-called "diamond ring" effect which
signals the climax of the event. Then, birds cease singing; flowers close;
bees cease their activities, the temperature drops, and a roseate glow
wreathes the moon's edges. The sky — displaying a milk-white crown of
light, the sun's corona, emanating in all directions, flashing and flaring
around the edges of the blackened disk — grows dark except near the
horizon where shadows and a faint reddish light commingle. In the sphere
of the Fixed Stars, the pilgrim is directed by [the absent] Beatrice to
look into what Eliot calls, in The Waste Land, "the heart of light,
the silence." This he does.
Overwhelmed by the subsequent vision,
the reborn poet made privy to the "revealed Name" — "The Being" — cannot
"recall what [the light] became at that moment"; nevertheless, his failure
to do poetic justice to his rapturous experience of the Trinity — an
experience that might well be described as "formless circumstance" —
deters him not at all. Instead, appropriately, he offers up a celebratory
hymn of praise, a powerful prayer concluding the consummate work of art to
become one with "the love that moves the sun and the other stars." For the
record, and of some value in the context of Ten New Songs, Dante
wraps up with a fanfare and flourish in the penultimate Canto of his
Divine Comedy:
... Grace from her hands who has the power
to help you. And you shall follow me so with your love That your
heart will not wander from my words.
And he began to say this holy
prayer:
Not surprisingly, Ten New Songs also closes with
a prayer:
Don't really have the courage To stand where I must
stand Don't really have the temperament To lend a helping
hand
Don't really know who sent me To raise my voice and
say May the lights in The Land of Plenty Shine on the truth some
day...
For the millions in a prison That wealth has set
apart For the Christ who has not risen From the caverns of the
heart
For the innermost decision That we cannot but obey For
what's left of our religion I lift my voice and pray May the lights
in The Land of Plenty Shine on the truth some day...
"Well,
that's a song that is in the tradition of a kind of protest song; but, I
tried to be careful to establish the fact that I had no credentials. Don't
really have the courage to stand where I must stand. We see the injustice;
we see the inequality; but, who has the courage to resist it? Who has the
knowledge of what to do? Don't really have the temperament to lend a
helping hand. Don't really know who sent me to raise my voice and say, May
the lights in the land of plenty shine on the truth someday. I don't know
what the motivation, what the impetus, what the urgency of this song is
all about. All I know is that I was compelled to say those words; but, I
wanted to make it clear in the song that I had no special qualifications
to utter this prayer."
Christ moves, works, and lives as a human
being among human beings, raising humanity from the guttermost to the
uttermost. The Prince of Glory — both archetypal and apocalyptic — makes
the Lord's hidden mysteries tangible, manifest, and irrefutably real; he
is the Logos of the Good Word. As Moses, Buddha, Confucius, Jesus, and
Muhammad are generally viewed as the founders of the world's principle
religions, the Good News is for all humanity, Christians, Jews, Muslims,
Hindus, Buddhists, agnostics, and atheists included.
Cohen,
formally educated, deeply and widely read, has often spoken of his abiding
love and respect for the book of Isaiah, the Psalms, and the Revelation,
all of which find their significant niches emphasising correlative aspects
of TNS's sphere of influence and reference.
"A sense of
global convulsion has always been present in my work," he'd recently told
Frank DiGiacomo, "people just credited it to my general morbid take on
things, that I wouldn’t join the celebration about the destruction of the
Berlin Wall ... It’s not that I wasn’t happy for people who no longer live
under tyrannies, but I also sensed that with the disintegration of the
Soviet empire there’d be great disorder, and that that was all that was
keeping the various tribes from cutting each other’s throats."
At
the same time, he told Brian D. Johnson (Maclean's) about the way
in which he's been "living in an exploded landscape for a long time. I
have a place to situate all of this. Because I've felt that things were
going to blow up — it wasn't as specific as the twin towers — but I've
felt for some time there was going to be a shaking of the
situation."
Absolutely true. A decade ago, Cohen told Bob Mackowitz
exactly that during an interview discussing The Future's
title-track: "... I think that Yeats's line, 'the centre will not hold,'
could very well have been the subtitle of the song. I say, you know,
'things are going to slide in all directions, nothing will be measured
anymore. The blizzard of the world has crossed the threshold, overturned
the order of the soul.' We're not even able to hold a concept now of a
resurrection mechanism; we don't even know what the concept is about, now.
We can't even locate it in our mental equipment. And, I do feel that the
centrality has dissolved.
"You know, we used to talk about the
broken family. We all have experienced the broken family, now — us! You
know, the people we were talking about — the sociologists, the
academicians, the poets, the mental workers — none of these things we
were talking about, from an observational point of view, has stayed as
objects of our conversation. So, we are living a world — in a daily life
— of such ambiguity — ambiguity about ourselves, about our wives, our
husbands, our loves, our families, our loyalties, our work — the
ambiguities have become intolerable. We are no longer outside the problem.
There no longer is a distance. There is no hill to see this from — you
share one body, now, with the serpent you forbid and with the dove that
you allow. We're in it.
"And, The Future comes out of that
experience. There is no perspective on the future anymore. It is like —
Look it! — you'll settle for the Berlin Wall. You'll settle for
totalitarianism. You'll settle for the FBI. You'll settle for the ozone
layer with the hole in it. You'll settle for the wrecked Amazonian forest.
All these things will look good, next to what's coming
down."
What's come down in the last decade? Your future, the future
of the global village, "a gathering around a perplexity." The blizzard has
crossed the threshold; the sacred heart's blown; we are now "living in an
exploded landscape" which admits of a tentative affirmation, an
acceptance.
"Look, he is coming with the clouds, and every eye will
see him, even those who pierced him; and all the peoples of the earth will
mourn because of him. So shall it be! Amen. 'I am the Alpha and the
Omega,' says the Lord God, 'who is, and who was, and who is to come, the
Almighty'" (Revelation 1).
If, as Cohen suggests, contemporary
culture supplants Nature, what remains worthy of worship in a world where
Nature no longer provides the raw materials, the almighty stuff that
heavens are made of?
In referring to King Claudius's couplet in
Hamlet, "My words fly up, my thoughts remain below: Words without
thoughts never to heaven go," Cohen reluctantly communicated his thoughts
on the situation in Israel to El Mundo's Elena Pita in September
2001. "Citing the words of the bard ('Oh,...my words... '), the greatness
of a religion is in affirming other religions, the way a great culture
affirms other cultures. I am conscious of putting a finger in a wound, but
the first thing that comes to my mind is the establishment of Jewish
colonies in the land of the Palestinians."
(Silence.)
"What
I think? That's a weighty question. My loyalty is compromised; I wish
everyone well; but, I am especially worried about the survival of Israel.
With the present Administration and its policy, Israel is somewhat of a
priority on my mind. But last week I was reading the Qur'an and it speaks
of reconciliation, of peace, of compassion. I have hope there will be a
solution, although I don't know what that would be. I know that it is
tragic, that the Palestinians need to find a place to live, as do the
Jews. The problem is that G-d has commanded them both to live on the same
site."
Despite the fact the entire Book of Revelation bears
scrutiny here, Revelation 6 (KJV) stands on its own and provides
substantial correlative food for thought in terms of some of the key
ingredients that have gone into the creation of the sumptuous feast of a
masterpiece known as Ten New Songs:
And I saw when the
Lamb opened one of the seals, and I heard, as it were the noise of
thunder, one of the four beasts saying, Come and see. And I saw, and
behold a white horse: and he that sat on him had a bow; and a crown was
given unto him: and he went forth conquering, and to conquer. And when he
had opened the second seal, I heard the second beast say, Come and see.
And there went out another horse that was red: and power was given to him
that sat thereon to take peace from the earth, and that they should kill
one another: and there was given unto him a great sword. And when he had
opened the third seal, I heard the third beast say, Come and see. And I
beheld, and lo, a black horse; and he that sat on him had a pair of
balances in his hand. And I heard a voice in the midst of the four beasts
say, A measure of wheat for a penny, and three measures of barley for a
penny; and see thou hurt not the oil and the wine. And when he had opened
the fourth seal, I heard the voice of the fourth beast say, Come and see.
And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was
Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the
fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with
death, and with the beasts of the earth. And when he had opened the fifth
seal, I saw under the altar the souls of them that were slain for the word
of God, and for the testimony which they held: And they cried with a loud
voice, saying, How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and
avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth? And white robes were
given unto every one of them; and it was said unto them, that they should
rest yet for a little season, until their fellow servants also and their
brethren, that should be killed as they were, should be fulfilled. And I
beheld when he had opened the sixth seal, and lo, there was a great
earthquake; and the sun became black as sackcloth of hair, and the moon
became as blood; And the stars of heaven fell unto the earth, even as a
fig tree casteth her untimely figs, when she is shaken of a mighty wind.
And Heaven departed as a scroll when it is rolled together; and every
mountain and island were moved out of their places. And the kings of the
earth, and the great men, and the rich men, and the chief captains, and
the mighty men, and every bond man, and every free man, hid themselves in
the dens and in the rocks of the mountains; And said to the mountains and
rocks, Fall on us, and hide us from the face of him that sitteth on the
throne, and from the wrath of the Lamb: For the great day of His wrath is
come; and who shall be able to stand?
The ponies run, the
girls are young The odds are there to beat You win a while, and then
it’s done Your little winning streak ...
And maybe I had miles
to drive And promises to keep You ditch it all to stay alive A
Thousand Kisses Deep ... .
REFERENCES AND RELATED LINKS:
The Leonard Cohen Files (Jarkko
and Rauli Arjatsalo)
Sony Canada's Official Leonard Cohen
Site
Sharon
Robinson
Ten New
Songs
The Divine Comedy
by Dante Alighieri

JF
in The
Gallery of Beautiful Losers
|
Award-winning Canadian poet, literary journalist, and
music critic Judith
Fitzgerald's accessible, compelling, and concise portrait,
Marshall McLuhan: Wise Guy (Quest Biography Series, XYZ, 206
pp.) — an exclusive excerpt from which was prominently featured on
the front of Canada's National Newspaper, The Globe and Mail
— was published to glowing reviews November 2001. Currently, the
ex-Torontonian who now calls Northern Ontario's Almaguin Highlands
home is writing Our Incomparable Sense of Loss: The Art and Craft
of the Words and Music of Leonard Cohen (Guernica Editions,
2003) — "Notes" is an exclusive draft preview from this book — and
completing Adagios
(a four-part long poem), Oberon Press will publish next year.
|
© 2002-2008 The Leonard Cohen Files (Electronic Edition) ©
2002-2008 Judith Fitzgerald (Print Edition)
All Rights
Reserved. Duplication in whole or in part in any medium without the
express written permission of the copyright holders is
forbidden. All TNS Lyrics cited by written permission. ©
2001-2008 Leonard Cohen, Sharon Robinson, and Sony/ATV Music
Publishing Canada Company. All Rights Reserved.
|